Core Concepts

Since 2022, the Together in Truth team has worked with three communities (Louisville, KY; Washington, D.C.; and Nambe Pueblo, NM) to support them in designing and implementing truth-telling circles. The experiences of these communities, led by former African American foster youth, impacted parents, and tribal leaders, respectively, led us to develop guidance materials to expand truth-telling practices across the country. With these communities and a national advisory committee representing impacted persons and those with professional child welfare experience, we have captured an array of core concepts that communities may use when embarking on a truth-telling journey.  

These core concepts presented as part of this guidance system were gathered through deliberate, complex, challenging and action-oriented conversations about truth-telling in child welfare.

Represented were the different viewpoints of Abolitionists, Safety-Centered Practitioners, Reformers, Transformers, and Institutionalists. Generally speaking, Abolitionists believe the child welfare/family-policing system needs to be dismantled and replaced with something entirely different. Safety-Centered Practitioners believe it is of the utmost importance that this system protect children from harm. Reformers believe the system is broken and needs to be improved, whereas Transformers believe this system is working as intended and still must be fundamentally redesigned. The Institutionalists believe that there is no alternative to the current system and that any change is impossible or undesirable. These are not five mutually exclusive categories but, rather, different ways of approaching the problem of policing and justice in our society. Our goal is to find common ground among these perspectives and acknowledge that on any point of this pentagon shape (or anywhere in between) there is, if nothing else, a requirement to tell the truth about the harms of our systems, historical and current, so that we may identify a better way together. In these spaces of diverse views, we welcome the complexity as an opportunity to practice the action of truth telling together, rather than in individual monolithic spaces. Gathering the perspectives and possibilities from these differences and exploring the space in the middle is where we can find common ground and creative solutions.

Staying in one’s corner only leads to a lack of change and progress. Through truth-telling, we believe that we may engage in wise disagreements and encounter different perspectives that challenge our assumptions and beliefs.

Through truth-telling, we imagine a just future. Sharing power means accessing decision-making, resources, information, and accountability. It means recognizing and honoring the dignity and agency of every person, especially those marginalized and oppressed by child welfare systems. It means working together as allies and accomplices, not as enemies or competitors.

As communities embark on truth-telling, the Together in Truth Team offers these core constructs as guideposts for communities’ consideration. This is not an exhaustive list. You may accept some, none or all of these core constructs. You can use them to generate other core constructs that are important to your community’s truth-telling efforts. Our interpretation does not have to resemble yours. We offer these humbly to support your community’s design of truth-telling circles.